Emerald Fennell's adaptation of 'Wuthering Heights,' starring Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi, has grossed approximately $82 million globally, maintaining its status as the year's biggest opening film. However, the film continues to face significant backlash from critics, particularly regarding its casting choices and thematic interpretation. Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett from The Guardian has criticized the adaptation for reducing the complex themes of class and race to a mere love story, stating, "By turning the novel into just a corset-heaving love story, the director has stripped it of what made it so boundary-pushing." The casting of Robbie, who is 35 and plays a character in her teens, and Elordi, who has been accused of 'whitewashing' Heathcliff, has intensified concerns, with critics noting that both actors are not from Yorkshire, further erasing regional authenticity. Cosslett remarked, "the erasure of regional authenticity risks going under-discussed," highlighting the broader issue of northern actors being overlooked for lead roles.
ENTERTAINMENT
Emerald Fennell's 'Wuthering Heights' Faces Backlash in Hollywood

Emerald Fennell's 'Wuthering Heights,' starring Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi, grossed $82M but faces backlash over casting, themes, and authenticity, sparking debates on adaptations of classics.
Detailed Analysis
COVERAGE ACROSS SOURCES
How different outlets covered this story.
8 outlets · 18 articles
Filter:
TG
The Guardian
Updated 13h agoWuthering Heights is at its heart a story of class and race. Emerald Fennell has got it all wrong | Rhiannon Lucy CosslettFEB 17, 10:00 AMRead →Wuthering slights: why are film-makers afraid of casting Yorkshire actors as Cathy Earnshaw?FEB 17, 9:03 AMRead →‘It was spooky’: folk singer Olivia Chaney on how a song reflecting her own Brontë-ish love triangle wound up in Wuthering HeightsFEB 16, 3:33 PMRead →Every generation gets the Wuthering Heights it deserves. And Emerald Fennell’s is for the always-online | Nadia KhomamiFEB 16, 11:57 AMRead →Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights is big movie with a very small mind | Adrian HortonFEB 16, 11:11 AMRead →Wuthering Heights rakes in $77m at global box office on opening weekendFEB 16, 3:21 AMRead →‘It’s not a documentary’: costume designers on ditching accuracy for spectacleFEB 13, 7:13 PMRead →
NNW
NBC News World
Updated 1 day agoGE
Geo Entertainment
Updated 1 day ago‘Wuthering Heights' opens with $76.8M, year's biggest box office debutFEB 16, 7:14 AMRead →Jacob Elordi, Margot Robbie's 'Wuthering Heights' controversial scene explainedFEB 15, 6:11 AMRead →Anne Hathaway shares intriguing warning about ‘Wuthering Heights' movieFEB 14, 10:58 AMRead →See Jacob Elordi's golden tooth while promoting ‘Wuthering Heights'FEB 13, 10:34 PMRead →
EV
evrimagaci
Updated 2 days agoTNP-E
The News Pakistan - Entertainment
Updated 3 days agoTH
the-independent
Updated 3 days agoTL
Tribune Latest
Updated 4 days agoHO
hollywoodoutbreak
Updated 4 days agoYT